HMRC wins £42k late filing penalty row
It's sometimes possible to appeal against a late filing penalty on the grounds that there was a “reasonable excuse” for the lateness. However, you have to be able to meet further conditions. How does a recent Upper Tribunal case demonstrate that a penalty can be upheld, even if there was a reasonable excuse?
In Harrison v HMRC [2022] UKUT 216, the taxpayer (H) believed that his advisors had submitted his 2014/15 tax return by the due date of 31 January 2016. H experienced a series of distressing events and was informed by his newly appointed advisors that his previous advisors had not submitted his last tax return. H admitted that sorting out his tax return was at the bottom of his priority list as he was dealing with various family and business problems. The return was finally submitted in September 2018. Whilst the courts accepted there was a reasonable excuse for the late filing, it could not be said that the return was submitted without reasonable delay. He had continued complex work on his business during the period. Therefore, the continued failure to submit the return resulted in an eye-watering tax geared penalty of £42,066 for deliberately withholding information. The appeal was dismissed.
This highlights a little-known fact that where the return is over twelve months late the penalties are based upon a percentage of the tax liability depending upon the taxpayer’s behaviour, i.e. deliberate/concealed. H endured several extremely difficult events and suffered from depression but was found to be capable of approving his tax return in spite of this.
Related Topics
-
Tribunal rejects reliance on adviser as reasonable excuse
A recent First-tier Tribunal decision has confirmed that relying on an accountant does not automatically amount to a reasonable excuse for missing a self-assessment deadline. The case highlights the limits of delegating tax responsibilities. What does this mean in practice?
-
HMRC issues new wave of offshore “nudge” letters
HMRC has issued a further round of “nudge” letters targeting individuals it believes may have undeclared offshore income or gains. The letters form part of HMRC’s ongoing use of data from international information exchange agreements. What should you do if you receive one?
-
Payroll changes for 2026/27
As the end of 2025/26 draws closer, HMRC has published a raft of updates and reminders for employers. Which changes do you need to be aware of that might impact your payroll in 2026/27?